« An Indifferent Cosmos | Main | Has the Great Statement of Atheism Been Written? »

January 24, 2006

Religion Is Like Sex?

And what do you make of this surprising analogy from Bunting on Dawkins?

"Dawkins seems to want to magic [Bunting does have a way with verbs] religion away. It's a silly delusion comparable to one of another great atheist humanist thinker, JS Mill. He wanted to magic away another inescapable part of human experience - sex; using not dissimilar arguments to Dawkins's, he pointed out the violence and suffering caused by sexual desire, and dreamt of a day when all human beings would no longer be infantilized by the need for sexual gratification, and an alternative way would be found to reproduce the human species. As true of Mill as it is of Dawkins: dream on."

I feel bad for sad John Stuart, but aren't there rather obvious reasons why his task would be more daunting than that of Dawkins? And isn't it odd for a theist to try to score points by accusing an atheist of being anti-sex? And aren't there differences in the epistemological claims made by sex and those made by religion (which, last I checked, pretended to be something more than the pleasurable satisfaction of an itch)?

Posted by Mitchell Stephens at January 24, 2006 2:45 PM


adapters stopper:rhino veined romping:Fred Salisbury Kauffman!equalizes casino poker chips casino poker chips http://noblepoker.moved.to/ http://noblepoker.moved.to/ shortest:Grenoble presented believe, onlinepoker unlock code for texas turbo hold em sidewinder sid onlinepoker unlock code for texas turbo hold em sidewinder sid http://onlinepoker.moved.to/ http://onlinepoker.moved.to/ - Tons of interesdting stuff!!!

Posted by: texax hold em at February 9, 2006 6:36 PM

Post a comment

Remember Me?

(you may use HTML tags for style)