« The NASA SCI Files: Problem-Based Learning Introduces Students to Scientific Inquiry | Main | Writing about Literature in the Media Age »
September 21, 2005
The Voyager Macbeth: An Expanded Critical Edition

Remember HyperCard? Apple's original, card-based graphical application made it possible to craft book-like works out of a database structure, allowing for multiple trajectories through the text and the intermingling of graphics and motion media. (Smackerel.net provides a nice refresher on "When Multimedia Was Black & White") Many of the works built in HyperCard have taken on the status of relics, but the best of them never fail to impress, reminding us that some of the biggest conceptual leaps in digital media were made over ten years ago, and in many ways remain unsurpassed.
The Voyager Macbeth is a HyperCard-based CD-ROM that blew the lid off what seemed possible in a critical edition of a literary text (view demo). The disc is structured around the 1993 New Cambridge edition of the play, introduced by David Rodes, and thoroughly annotated by A.C. Braunmuller - both leading Shakespeare scholars and professors at UCLA. Producer and chief programmer Michael Cohen describes it as "a rich, immersive, book-like experience" - "a layered format." The text can be read, searched, listened to, watched, and even recited out loud with a pre-recorded actor reading opposite (a feature called "Macbeth Karaoke"). Trevor Nunn's seminal 1976 Royal Shakespeare Company production with Ian McKellan and Judy Dench supplies a complete audio track that can be brought into action instantly with a mouse click, beginning on any desired line. One can read the entire text this way, the pages turning automatically, with the impeccable cast of the RSC bringing it to life like a radio play.

Each page is rich with annotations, which can be summoned as pop-up windows by clicking on underlined words or passages. You can also click on little dagger icons in the margins that provide further context or tie a speech to other moments and motifs in the play, or little film strip icons that indicate video clips are available. Here opens another region of this vast edition. The editors have provided lengthy clips, with commentary, from three of the greatest screen adaptations of Shakespeare's tragedy - Orson Welles' Macbeth (1948), Akira Kurosawa's Throne of Blood (1957), and Roman Polanski's The Tragedy of Macbeth (1971) - all of which can be viewed (albeit on a small screen - this would be different now) within the book.

Other assets that expand the universe of the play and deepen the reader's investigation include a lengthy introduction by Professor Rodes, a library of critical essays, detailed background on Shakespeare's life and Elizabethan context, excerpts from the Holinshed Chronicles from which the play is drawn, a large archive of images documenting Macbeth's influence on western culture and various stage productions through the centuries, and important analytical tools such as character profiles, scene summaries and analysis, a full text concordance, and collation with other versions of the play (indispensable in Shakespeare scholarship). The only thing lacking, which could no doubt be solved if The Voyager Macbeth were being remade today, is the ability to write one's own notes in the text and to mark specific sections.


Chatting with Michael Cohen, I asked why so few electronic works of this caliber have been produced since the mid 90s. He pointed to the world wide web, which came into public use just as CD-ROMs were hitting their stride, and had the unfortunate effect of all but halting this period of development. "The web enables the making of small things." To some extent these things can be woven together, but the web is fundamentally not good at providing a center, which is essential for serious scholarship and textual analysis. "There is a place," he continued, "for well-considered, architected book-like materials." These materials should be able to weave together rich media and text in a way that paper cannot, yet still retain the focus and coherence of bounded print materials.
"But," I asked, "isn't the network something that should be used productively in these 'book-like' objects? There are resources on the web that can be of use, not to mention opportunities to communicate and work collaboratively with other students through the book. 'Macbeth Karaoke,' for instance, could incorporate a live chat tool that would make it possible to read with scene partners over the web." Or, students could interpret the text collaboratively with the Ivanhoe game (also profiled on nexttext). He agreed that the network should be fully employed, and that hopefully, tools would be developed that enabled the relatively easy production of bounded, media-rich works that can piggy-back on the web and draw on all the affordances of networked space. This suggests a vision of the future textbook that exists comfortably in the context of the web, and yet is not entirely of the web. Like a boat in the stream, it retains all the rigors and cohesion of the material world.
Cohen sees great potential in the recent increase in high school and university programs that provide laptops to every student. They'll need to load something on to that equipment, something more disciplined than a web browser. When you have unbroken access to your own machine, you can dive deeper - perhaps there is the potential for rich, immersive educational materials to make an entrance in programs like these.
Posted by ben vershbow at September 21, 2005 08:17 AM
Comments
the making of small things
I was particularly struck by Michael Cohen's idea that "The web enables the making of small things." To some extent these things can be woven together, but the web is fundamentally not good at providing a center, which is essential for serious scholarship and textual analysis. To that I would say, yes and no. Unlike the CD Roms of the 90's, you don't need much money or expertise to make a website. Perhaps that is why we have so many small things, but even in the heyday of CDs, there was nothing like the monolithic wikipedia. And most major cultural institutions are building vast, sprawling sites with archived resources, guided tours, educational mini-sites that far surpass what used to exist on CD.
I totally agree that the "There is a place for well-considered, architected book-like materials." But he suggests that well-considered and book-like always go together and I don't think that is necessarily the case.
Posted by: kim white at September 28, 2005 10:34 PM
You can take notes!
Ben wrote:
"The only thing lacking, which could no doubt be solved if The Voyager Macbeth were being remade today, is the ability to write one's own notes in the text and to mark specific sections."
Ben, you can mark passages and attach annotations, then export your annotations along with the quoted passage and a citation. I use this feature every time I teach. There was no way poor Michael, Colin Holgate or Brock LaPorte would have had any peace at all if this feature hadn't been in Mackers. This is a marvelous way to create student papers or scholarly articles, because you then export your notes, the passages and the citation as the core of your own paper. Or you send the exported file to another Mackers user who can import your notes and see them on their own copy -- again an innovation that proves that Voyager and Bob really get the fact that digital data is liquid.
If you click to the right of a passage, and drag, you should get a black line marker -- this indicates that there's a reader's note. Click the line to bring up an annotation window )thanks to Brock LaPorte's clever OWindows xcmd. You can see a page with notes if you look here on my site:
http://www.digitalmedievalist.com/bibs/mackers.html
I expect, if you're running Mackers on an OS X box under classic, the processor is too fast for the HyperTalk script; I modified the copy I taught with.
Posted by: Lisa Spangenberg (not verified) at October 29, 2005 01:38 PM
classic...
I stand humbly corrected. Of course! Everything Voyager made allowed for comments. I think it probably was a problem with running it in Classic.
Posted by: ben vershbow at October 31, 2005 04:06 PM
But wait . . there's MORE!
I forgot . . .
Mackers incorporated the "dog ear" corner click used in the Expanded Books, but added a pop-up note field for a short comment. So you can mark pages with a note as well.
Posted by: Lisa Spangenberg (not verified) at November 19, 2005 03:18 PM
Wow, it's been a long time since I thought about the OWindow xcmd. That was a very fun project, and Voyager was an awesome, creative place. Hello to Lisa and Michael!
Posted by: Brock at April 27, 2006 11:47 PM