« the open library | Main | edit the galaxy »

darker side of youtube   07.20.2007, 11:50 AM

posted by ben vershbow

There's a good piece in Slate by Nick Douglas, a writer and video blogger out of San Francisco, that casts YouTube as the Hollywood of web video—purveyor of bite-sized crap with mass appeal, while the smaller, more innovative "independents" (the Groupers, Vimeos and blip.tvs) struggle in its shadow. YouTube's dominance, Douglas argues, leads viewers to expect less of a fledgeling cultural arena that could become the leading edge of filmmaking but instead has been made synonymous with shallow, momentary titillation.

Douglas' critique is on target, and it's vital to keep questioning the so-called diversity of the mega-aggregators who increasingly dominate the Web, but I wonder whether serious video producers really ought to be looking to YouTube and its competitors as the ultimate venue. As promotional and browsing sites they work well, but a networked, non-Web video client like Miro could be a better forum for challenging work.

Posted by ben vershbow on July 20, 2007 11:50 AM
tags: film, socialmedia, video, youtube

comments (0):

(Because of spam troubles, first-time comments from unfamiliar addresses or containing multiple links might be held for moderation. If your comment isn't spam, we'll publish it very soon. Thanks in advance for your patience.)