Comments by

dmsilver

Go to Text
III. Institution-Building, paragraph 11

this is the only mention of libraries in the body of this essay.

Go to Text
I. Overview, paragraph 9

i’d suggest replacing Friendster with facebook.

Go to Text
II. HASTAC: A History, paragraph 6

the events that HASTAC has organized, or is currently organizing, are really inspired. that said, i strongly believe that engaging undergraduates in digital media and culture is so much more *productive* than engaging graduate students. i am not suggesting either – or. however, i would like to hear more about how peer-to-peer learning affects undergraduate digital literacy and digital creation.

conferences that attract faculty and graduate students already exist. what we need, i think, are massively distributed digital projects designed and built by massively distributed undergraduates.

Go to Text
IV. Conclusion, paragraph 4

U Tube should be YouTube.

Go to Text
III. Institution-Building, paragraph 12

i strongly encourage the authors to rethink the notion of institutions as mobilizing networks but this time insert libraries into the mix. academic libraries are:

* the cultural and intellectual hearts of campuses;
* the physical spaces where interdisplinarity works best and most often;
* unlike professors who often hoard knowledge, libraries are tasked with disseminating and sharing knowledge;
* many libraries are immune (or somewhat immune) to the turf wars that mark disciplinary work. getting multiple academic libraries to collaborate is infinately easier, i believe, than getting multiple, say, english departments to collaborate.

i strongly encourage the authors to consider the role of academic libraries in the future of learning institutions in a digital age.

Go to Text
IV. Conclusion, paragraph 15

the comments page (which doesn’t allow comments – thus, i’m commenting here) says: “This page contains a running transcript of all conversations taking place inside the Iraq Study Group Report.” yikes!

Go to Text
II. HASTAC: A History, paragraph 7

how about including hyperlinks to all HASTAC events? so, in this case, hyperlinking to Cyberinfrastructure for the Humanities, Arts, and Social Sciences, to technoSpheres, etc. then readers can get a sense of the richness of these events.

also, in general, i suggest linking as much as possible!